Education and citizen science

Wiki NME Podium
 

Education and citizen science

Arjen Wals24 mei 2014 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

Education and citizen science; the missing pieces in the sustainability puzzle, according to article in Science Magazine

 

Two weeks ago a lengthy article on the education in the context of sustainability and climate change appeared in one of the world’s most prominent international newspapers: the International New York Times (see previous blog post about this with a link to the article). Today, May 9th 2014, represents another milestone in the development of education for people and planet: one of the most prominent journals in science ‘Science’ published a paper on the importance of creating synergies between science education and environmental education with the support of Citizen Science.

 

The article, which I co-authored with Justin Dillon, Bob Stevenson and Michael Brody, is based on the trends emerging from the International Handbook of Environmental Education Research (Stevenson et al, 2013)*. There are a number of lessons to be drawn but essentially we emphasize the importance of:

 

Connecting biophilia and videophilia: that is, study ways in which ever-present technologies and cyberspaces can be used to help people (re)gain a deeper and more empathetic contact with each other and with the world (presently these technologies and spaces tend to lead to the exact opposite).

 

Creating spaces for hybrid learning: that is, hybridized environments and new spaces are needed for learning about the sustainability challenges of our time (e.g. climate change, malnutrition, loss of food security and biodiversity) that embraces the authenticity of multiple voices and cultural and theoretical perspectives, new forms of representation, and more change-oriented and community-based approaches.

 

Strengthening community-engaged scholarship with a planetary conscience: that is, with the increasing complexity of societies, the interdisciplinary nature of people-society-environment relationships, the problems faced at local and global scale, and the uncertainty of their solutions or resolutions, there is a need for new spaces for collaborative and transformative approaches to research.

 

Supporting emerging forms of ICT-supported Citizen Science: that is, the active involvement of citizens, young and old, in the monitoring of local socio-ecological issues by collecting real data and sharing those data with others doing the same elsewhere through social media and on-line platforms, as a catalyst for realizing the first three points.

 

Furthermore we suggest that future research address:

 

  • the importance of acknowledging different ways of knowing into educational program(me)s;
  • the importance of place-based education;
  • the need for EE to focus on community-based activities that lead to
  • the individual and group empowerment;
  • the need to factor in issues of identity in EE;
  • the need for a convergence of science education and environmental education;
  • the need for EE to address issues of life-long learning
  • the need for practitioners and researchers to address policy issues;
  • the need for inter- and transdisciplinarity in EE practice and research.

 

On a critical note, not so much stressed in the Science article but noted in the Handbook, we plea for stressing the importance of education serving people and planet rather than just serving the economy. The current push for innovation, competence, and a lifelong of learning for work and competitiveness, is resulting in the marginalization in education of people and by squeezing out place-based learning, arts, humanities and the development of values other than those driving consumerism and materialism.

 

Wals, A.E.J., Brody, M., Dillon, J. and Stevenson, R.B. (2014) Convergence Between Science and Environmental Education, Science, 344, p. 583-584.

 

Here is a link to the article on the Science Website – you may need to go through your library to get it.

 

* Stephenson, B., Brody, M., Dillon, J. and Wals, A.E.J. (Eds.) (2013) International Handbook of Environmental Education Research. London: Routledge.

 

Below you will find today’s press release by Wageningen University & Research Centre.

 

Press release Wageningen University, no. 045, 9 May 2014

 

“Addressing climate change, requires a change of mind”

Sustainability needs link between theory and practice in education

 

How can you ensure that people do not only spend time thinking about important global issues like climate change or world food supplies, but also roll up their sleeves and do something about them? Four researchers, including Professor Arjen Wals from Wageningen University, think that the education sector holds the key. Teaching processes around the world could be given more influence and meaning by making pure science subjects, such as biology and physics, complementary to lessons in nature, environment and sustainability. Their article on this new approach to teaching, which is based on citizen science, is published in the 9 May edition of Science.

 

Throughout the world, ‘pure’ science subjects such as physics, chemistry, biology, maths, geography and general natural sciences, which traditionally aim to build up knowledge and understanding, are seen separately from subjects such as nature and the environment, which together with the latest branch ‘sustainability education’ take a more practical approach. Although this certainly makes scholars aware of the current condition of our planet, their lack of practical perspective evokes a sense of powerlessness. For example, what can you do to prevent or respond adequately to forthcoming climate shifts? Affinity with politics, society and the economy are essential in this respect. Conversely, education in nature, the environment and sustainability (aka ‘environmental education’) does not equip scholars with the scientific insight they need to back up their proposed remedies.

 

Convergence

When taught separately, natural sciences and environmental education give a disjointed answer to society’s demand for a truly sustainable society. “It’s time these two schools converged,” says Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development at Wageningen University. “If we cannot create a firm link between these two educational areas, scientific education is in jeopardy of becoming purely a vehicle for enhancing the innovative and competitive potential of a country’s economy”, he says. “At the same time, without a firm link with the sciences, environmental education will never be able to find a responsible and realistic way of dealing with the contradictions and uncertainties that are raised in the scientific debate surrounding questions of sustainability.”

The authors of the article in Science give a number of examples of environmental education, which cover the area where science meets society. Among them is the American concept of Edible School Gardens, whereby schoolchildren grow their own food in an educational garden while simultaneously learning about the things they grow in science lessons. The Dutch version is known as Groene schoolpleinen (‘green school grounds’). Another good example is YardMap, based on IT and citizen science. Citizens, both young and old, analyse biodiversity in their own neighbourhood by means of digital photos, special apps and Google Maps. The aim is to identify the areas with the greatest potential for boosting biodiversity. Action plans designed to ensure that the YardMaps are kept fully up-to-date are drawn up and implemented on the basis of studies and in consultation with scientists and local partners (including the municipal authority, garden centres and an NGO). The various YardMaps are linked via social media. The Dutch Natuurkalender works in much the same way.

 

Creating closer ties between citizen science, scientific education and environmental education will help citizens and scientists to take a meaningful and practical approach to the pursuit of sustainability. Wals: “It’s not just about linking up the content; it involves developing new competencies such as dealing with complexity, uncertainty and confusion, and devising and implementing meaningful local solutions”. This method of learning may also help to restore the damage to public confidence in science. The government will have to put more effort into stimulating and supporting the ‘hybrid teaching environments’ that blur the boundaries between science and society, school and neighbourhood, local and global, and shift the emphasis to the wellbeing of mankind and the planet.

 

Transition

Calls for transition and another way of thinking are becoming more urgent, says Professor Wals: “At the end of the day, the climate problem is as much in between our ears, as it is between the North and South Poles”. He backs this up with a remarkable conclusion: to his mind, the role of education and citizen involvement has been seriously underemphasised in the climate debate. In fact he wonders if we will ever be able to bring about a transition without committed, critical and competent citizens, who aspire to values that are not purely based on the material side of their existence but also on care for fellow human beings and, indeed, other species, here and elsewhere, now and in the future.

 

Join in the discussion on #CitizenScience

 

Publication

Wals, A.E.J., Brody, M., Dillon, J. and Stevenson, R.B. (2014) Convergence Between Science and Environmental Education, Science, 344, p. 583-584.

 

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Meer duurzame scholen noordelijke provincies door samenwerking

13-02-2017 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Mars Ambassador Program

05-12-2016 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Buurtbaten

13-06-2016 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Stan Frijters

Leren voor Duurzame Ontwikkeling. Gewoon doen!

07-03-2016 - Stan Frijters, Projectleider/docent Stoas Vilentum Hoogeschool

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Groen Gaat Goed

15-02-2016 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Veranderen door de ‘grootst mogelijke kleine stap’

14-09-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

 Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Sociale verzorgingsstaat of een sociale samenleving?

27-07-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Bart de Koning

Cursus Peuters in het Wild

18-05-2015 - Bart de Koning, Natuur is een feest

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Samen leven in de energieke samenleving

04-05-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Reisleiders in Duurzaamheid

16-03-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, directeur SME Advies

 

Jeroen Onck

NME make-over

22-01-2015 - Jeroen Onck, Senior adviseur Utrecht Natuurlijk

 

Jan van Boeckel

Artbased environmental education

24-12-2014 - Jan van Boeckel, Adjunct and Program Director in Design Theory at Iceland Academy of the Arts

 

Vivian Siebering

Bomen groeien níet tot in de hemel

14-11-2014 - Vivian Siebering, Eigenaar ViSie Training & Advies

 

Linda IJmker

Laatste dag UNESCO Conferentie

12-11-2014 - Linda IJmker, Manager GroenGelinkt

 

Linda IJmker

Shaping the future we want

11-11-2014 - Linda IJmker, Manager GroenGelinkt

 

Linda IJmker

GroenGelinkt in het Japans

09-11-2014 - Linda IJmker, Manager GroenGelinkt

 

Jeroen Onck

Natuur biedt leerzame perspectieven. NME omarmt “Leren van de natuur”

20-08-2014 - Jeroen Onck, Senior consulent natuur, milieu en duurzaamheid bij Gemeente Utrecht

 

Petra Jansen, Farasha Educatief

Een andere blik op een betere wereld

14-07-2014 - Petra Jansen, Farasha Educatief , Petra Jansen werkt bij Veldwerk Nederland, geeft les op de Marnix Academie en heeft een eigen bedrijfje Farasha Educatief. www.farasha-educatief.org

 

Chantal Overgaauw

Regels frustreren vergroening buitenruimte

03-07-2014 - Chantal Overgaauw, Woordlicht, communiceert over natuur en NME, traint docenten/pedagogisch medewerkers en neemt kinderen mee naar buiten.

 

Hak van Nispen

Meestribbelaars

16-06-2014 - Hak van Nispen, Directeur SME Advies

 

Arjen Wals

Education and citizen science

24-05-2014 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

A.A. Mabelis (Bram)

Vrije tijdsbesteding van kinderen

24-04-2014 - A.A. Mabelis (Bram), Externe medewerker, Alterra Wageningen UR

 

Chantal Overgaauw, Woordlicht

Regen

12-02-2014 - Chantal Overgaauw, Woordlicht, communiceert over natuur en NME, traint docenten/pedagogisch medewerkers en neemt kinderen mee naar buiten.

 

Jeroen Onck

Nieuwjaarsfabel

06-01-2014 - Jeroen Onck, Senior consulent natuur, milieu en duurzaamheid bij Gemeente Utrecht

 

Jeroen Onck

De ongemakkelijke nuance

17-11-2013 - Jeroen Onck, Senior consulent natuur, milieu en duurzaamheid bij Gemeente Utrecht

 

 Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Scholen zijn rampzalig!

24-10-2013 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Eerste dinsdag van september is nieuwe Prinsjesdag

02-09-2013 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Arjen Wals

Why sustainability cannot and should not be taught: a call for reflexivity, transformation and deep learning in turbulent times

04-03-2013 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

Arjen Wals

Fifty Shades of Green – why the Green Economy cannot be business as usual and ESD cannot be education as usual…

01-11-2012 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

Arjen Wals

Action Research & Community Problem Solving and The Acoustics of Social Learning

21-09-2012 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

Jeroen Onck

Nestwarmte, duurzame bron van energie?

29-06-2012 - Jeroen Onck,

 

NMEpodium is een samenwerkingsverband van IVN, GDO, Veldwerk Nederland, SMEAdvies en VVM Sectie NME en is financieel mogelijk door het Ministerie van Economische Zaken, Landbouw en Innovatie.