Why sustainability cannot and should not be taught: a call for reflexivity, transformation and deep learning in turbulent times

Wiki NME Podium
 

Why sustainability cannot and should not be taught: a call for reflexivity, transformation and deep learning in turbulent times

Arjen Wals04 maart 2013 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

This academic year I have the honour of participating in the academic community of Gothenburg University as the Adlerbert Research Foundation’s Guest Professor. Gothenburg University, as does the other well-known university in Gothenburg, Chalmers University, aspires to integrate sustainability science and education in all its 7 faculties. The two universities already share a Centre for Environment and Sustainability (GMV) and Chalmers has a special Sustainability Vice-Chancellor, John Holmberg who is also a UNESCO Chair in Education for Sustainability in Higher Education. During my last visit to Gothenburg in this new role I participated in a workshop on Teacher Education for Sustainable Development? which was introduced with the following text:High expectations of formal education’s contribution to sustainable development are expressed in a series of policy documents from UNESCO, through the proclaimed Decade of Education for Sustainable Development (2005-2014). This is also highlighted in Swedish policy documents for education (National Agency for Education). The Swedish Higher Education Act states that “In the course of their operations, higher education institutions shall promote sustainable development to assure for present and future generations a sound and healthy environment, economic and social welfare, and justice”. What implications does this have for a higher education program such as Teacher Education?

 

Julie Davis of the Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Australia and I were asked to provide input for the workshop by providing a ‘provocative’ introduction. Mine was titled: Why sustainability cannot and should not be taught: a call for reflexivity, transformation and deep learning in turbulent times.

 

Needless to say that the title raised some eyebrows. But here’s what I tried to say. We cannot know what sustainability is. We don’t live long enough to be able to say that what we consider to be sustainable today turned out to be sustainable in the end. Also, what might be sustainable in Gothenburg, Sweden might not be sustainable in Kampala, Uganda. To complicate things further even when considering all the (scientific) knowledge available today there is no universal agreement about what, given what we know today, might be the most sustainable way of living.

 

So how then can we educate for sustainability? – a question already raised 20 years ago by my Canadian colleague and friend Bob Jickling.  In my contribution I problematized this dilemma from an education perspective by arguing that even though we do not and cannot know what sustainability is we have a moral responsibility to always be looking for ways of living that are more sustainable than our current ways.The current state of the Planet demands this. Given this dilemma it would be inappropriate or at least un-educative to use education to prescribe learners how to live their lives or to condition them to behave in a certain way.

 

Rather than focussing as educators on sustainability as a ‘destiny’ or an ‘end point’ it may be more fruitful and certainly more educational, to focus on the type of learning and the type of capacities that are needed to break away from unsustainable routines which are all around and generally known. Using concrete examples, I proposed strenghtening social and transformative learning in ‘cross-boundary environments’ seeking to develop people’s sustainability competence as an alternative. Some of these ideas can also be found in my inaugural address of a few years ago: Message-in-a-bottle-Learning-our-way-out-of-Unsustainability(pdf connected to the hypelink). I have attached the slides I used here: ESD-TE Workshop Gothenburg U November 2012.

 

Julie Davis talked about: Working the system: Taking a systems approach to embedding education for sustainability in teacher education in Australia

 

Here’s how here contribution was listed in the workshop outline: Much has been written about the need to ‘re-orient teacher education towards sustainability’. Yet, research indicates that, generally speaking, teacher education institutions are not preparing pre-service teachers to teach education for sustainability. This presentation reports on a staged study that commenced in 2006 in Australia that has sought to understand how change is implemented and becomes ‘mainstreamed’ within teacher education institutions. Stage 1 involved an international literature review and interviews to examine efforts to re-orient teacher education towards sustainability; consequently, a systems-based model for change was developed. In Stage 2 (2008), this model was piloted across 5 teacher education institutions in Queensland, Australia, aimed at engaging teacher education institutions and a range of stakeholders within a teacher education system to work simultaneously to bring about change. Findings indicated that systemic change is enabled if there is both conceptual and personal capacity for change, and that trust, respect and ownership are central to re-orienting teacher education systems. Stage 3 (2009) involved another 5 teacher education institutions that used the model to begin the task of reorienting their teacher education systems. This stage identified 5 enabling actions: collaborative curriculum change; building a sustainability ethos; connecting disparate sources of sustainability education content; better support for integration between programs; and utilising experiential teaching and learning approaches. Stage 4 (2011) is underway, aimed at deepening and extending the change experiences, with an emphasis on building a national network to drive systemic change for education for sustainability.

 

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Meer duurzame scholen noordelijke provincies door samenwerking

13-02-2017 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Mars Ambassador Program

05-12-2016 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Buurtbaten

13-06-2016 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Stan Frijters

Leren voor Duurzame Ontwikkeling. Gewoon doen!

07-03-2016 - Stan Frijters, Projectleider/docent Stoas Vilentum Hoogeschool

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Groen Gaat Goed

15-02-2016 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Veranderen door de ‘grootst mogelijke kleine stap’

14-09-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

 Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Sociale verzorgingsstaat of een sociale samenleving?

27-07-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Bart de Koning

Cursus Peuters in het Wild

18-05-2015 - Bart de Koning, Natuur is een feest

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Samen leven in de energieke samenleving

04-05-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Reisleiders in Duurzaamheid

16-03-2015 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, directeur SME Advies

 

Jeroen Onck

NME make-over

22-01-2015 - Jeroen Onck, Senior adviseur Utrecht Natuurlijk

 

Jan van Boeckel

Artbased environmental education

24-12-2014 - Jan van Boeckel, Adjunct and Program Director in Design Theory at Iceland Academy of the Arts

 

Vivian Siebering

Bomen groeien níet tot in de hemel

14-11-2014 - Vivian Siebering, Eigenaar ViSie Training & Advies

 

Linda IJmker

Laatste dag UNESCO Conferentie

12-11-2014 - Linda IJmker, Manager GroenGelinkt

 

Linda IJmker

Shaping the future we want

11-11-2014 - Linda IJmker, Manager GroenGelinkt

 

Linda IJmker

GroenGelinkt in het Japans

09-11-2014 - Linda IJmker, Manager GroenGelinkt

 

Jeroen Onck

Natuur biedt leerzame perspectieven. NME omarmt “Leren van de natuur”

20-08-2014 - Jeroen Onck, Senior consulent natuur, milieu en duurzaamheid bij Gemeente Utrecht

 

Petra Jansen, Farasha Educatief

Een andere blik op een betere wereld

14-07-2014 - Petra Jansen, Farasha Educatief , Petra Jansen werkt bij Veldwerk Nederland, geeft les op de Marnix Academie en heeft een eigen bedrijfje Farasha Educatief. www.farasha-educatief.org

 

Chantal Overgaauw

Regels frustreren vergroening buitenruimte

03-07-2014 - Chantal Overgaauw, Woordlicht, communiceert over natuur en NME, traint docenten/pedagogisch medewerkers en neemt kinderen mee naar buiten.

 

Hak van Nispen

Meestribbelaars

16-06-2014 - Hak van Nispen, Directeur SME Advies

 

Arjen Wals

Education and citizen science

24-05-2014 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

A.A. Mabelis (Bram)

Vrije tijdsbesteding van kinderen

24-04-2014 - A.A. Mabelis (Bram), Externe medewerker, Alterra Wageningen UR

 

Chantal Overgaauw, Woordlicht

Regen

12-02-2014 - Chantal Overgaauw, Woordlicht, communiceert over natuur en NME, traint docenten/pedagogisch medewerkers en neemt kinderen mee naar buiten.

 

Jeroen Onck

Nieuwjaarsfabel

06-01-2014 - Jeroen Onck, Senior consulent natuur, milieu en duurzaamheid bij Gemeente Utrecht

 

Jeroen Onck

De ongemakkelijke nuance

17-11-2013 - Jeroen Onck, Senior consulent natuur, milieu en duurzaamheid bij Gemeente Utrecht

 

 Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Scholen zijn rampzalig!

24-10-2013 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden

Eerste dinsdag van september is nieuwe Prinsjesdag

02-09-2013 - Hak van Nispen tot Pannerden, Directeur SME Advies

 

Arjen Wals

Why sustainability cannot and should not be taught: a call for reflexivity, transformation and deep learning in turbulent times

04-03-2013 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

Arjen Wals

Fifty Shades of Green – why the Green Economy cannot be business as usual and ESD cannot be education as usual…

01-11-2012 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

Arjen Wals

Action Research & Community Problem Solving and The Acoustics of Social Learning

21-09-2012 - Arjen Wals, Professor of Social Learning and Sustainable Development

 

Jeroen Onck

Nestwarmte, duurzame bron van energie?

29-06-2012 - Jeroen Onck,

 

NMEpodium is een samenwerkingsverband van IVN, GDO, Veldwerk Nederland, SMEAdvies en VVM Sectie NME en is financieel mogelijk door het Ministerie van Economische Zaken, Landbouw en Innovatie.